I own a number of lenses, all various zooms with the exception of my favourite 60mm f2.8 lens which I use mainly for studio work. Until recently I have been quite content with the quality of my photography using these lenses. I started to find that during wedding and event photography where the lighting was poor there were a number of images that were not of good enough quality to deliver to the client, which was a real shame as some of these shots would have been really striking images.
Now like all photographers I read articles and reviews of new equipment just to keep up with where things are heading. However, I am a commited cynic regarding the vast majority of these equipment reviews as to me they always make this months exciting new lens/camera/card/toothpick etc etc etc sound like you must have it or else you will never, ever, be able to take a decent photograph. From my part whenever I make a new purchase I normally end up feeling slightly dissapointed as I feel it doesn’t actually deliver what it has stated in all the exciting reviews. So, after much thought I came to the conclusion that in order to resolve my issues I needed to invest in some f2.8 professional lenses, specifically the Nikon 70-200 f2.8 and 24-70 f2.8. I did not take this decision lightly as these things don’t come cheap. I started reading the many reviews of these lenses on the internet and sure enough it was difficult to find a bad one, every review promised fantastic images, vibrant contrast, super fast focussing, wonderful low light abilities etc etc In short if I bought these lenses I would never, ever take a bad photograph again
Back in the real world my cynicsm had kicked in could these lenses really be that good? Did I really need these lenses? Would my problem be resolved by buying the new lenses? I compromised. I decided to buy a second hand 70-200 f2.8 (as with the recent release of a VRII version of this lens the second hand prices of the VRI models had dropped slightly) and a new 24-70 f2.8 as there was little difference between new and secondhand prices (this surely had to be a good sign of the quality of the lens).
Well the lenses arrived on Friday and even though the secondhand 70-200 f2.8 looked like it had been used in a war zone it was in good working order with no marks on the optics. The 24-70 was all shiny and new and waiting to be mounted up and start working.
So lets start with the Nikon 24-70 f2.8:
Immediately didn’t like it. Damn this cynical thing. It just didn’t feel right as the zoom ring was situated right at the bottom of the lens barrel next to the camera. It didn’t sit easily in my hand with my camera holding technique. I did realise that this was just something that I was not use to so a slight change in my normal camera handling was required. So, from initial dissapointment I moved on. Was it fast, yes. Did it focus faster than my other zoom lenses, yes. Would it make a difference to my photography? I won’t know until the wedding and event season starts. For sure it won’t make a difference just because it focusses faster to my fine art or product photography. Tried some indoor, poor light shots at f2.8. I did manage to get a decent shutter speed out of the camera with the lens which before I wouldn’t have managed to get. I also took a lot of handheld shots at 1/20s and 1/30s and couldn’t help feeling that VR would have been a useful addition to the lens.
Now, when I got the images out of the camera and into post processing I was a very, very, happy photographer. I compared the images with similar images taken with my other zooms and they are indeed significantly better. The first thing to stirke me was sharpness. This lens is sharp, so sharp I think I can do away with the unsharp mask! Secondly the images have a lovely contrast and last but not least bokeh. Beautiful bokeh, I think I will shoot at f2.8 now forever
So, overall on a satisfaction rating from the initial experience I would go for an 8/10 for this lens.
Nikon 70-200 f2.8 VRI:
It’s big, it’s heavy, it looks knocked about but it’s solid. First thing I noticed about using a lens of this size is how conscious I feel when I point it at somebody, it just feels so intimidating! The handling of the lens for something of such gargantuan proportions felt just right, the zoom ring was exactly where my hand felt it should be. All the zooming on this beast occurs inside the barrel so there are no bits of lens moving up and down on the outside. So, off I went to take pictures. It zoomed, it focussed it all seemed to work.
Back in post processing and ………………………………. WOW!!!!! This lens is good. How good I hear you ask? Damn good! Wonderful, wonderful colours (and that is from someone who loves black and white!) and a soft creamy bokeh that is indeed exceptional. Absolutley no vignetting and as sharp as a very sharp pin. I was taking handheld shots at 1/20s of people (ie things that move) and 90% of these shots were absolutely spot on, clear and vibrant. With my old lenses these shots would have been lost or I would have had to resort to flash.
As for a rating I’m going for a 9.5/10 as nothing is perfect.
In summary, am I happy. Yes and I can’t wait for the wedding season to start to use these two lenses for real.